Velia Alvidrez-Aguirre
Jane’s objective to have students
work collaboratively in a blended environment, conducting a research, and
creating a document on wikkispaces is great idea. However during the process of this assignment
there is more than one thing that went wrong.
Generally speaking issues will arise from group work. In some instances the main problem is the
lack of participation of all members of a group. This for sure is the case in Jane’s
circumstance where it is evident that some groups are having a difficult time
collaborating in a fair manner. This is leading from some group members to be
disengage and not contributing to the project. Another problem Jane is facing is the fact
that students are struggling to collaborate in a positive manner in an online
project. The lack of guidance
contributed to students deleting and disrespecting their peer’s work. The lack of objectivity from some groups is
also another issue that needs to be addressed.
These groups are solely focusing on the aesthetic component however how
can they refocus in researching their topic and gathering the pertinent
information. Jane could have guided
students by providing a clear goal and objectivity of the research paper to
prevent this issue.
The main issue is that some groups
deviated from the objective. Students
should always be clear on what the objective and goal is. The student’s creativity should be
acknowledged and praised, however as teachers we have to be vigilant that we
provide the necessary information to them to say on target. This is the time for Jane to bring the class
together and share strategies for students to analyze the assignment and the
expectations of it. This to me is the
main issue because time is valuable and students should use it wisely to
accomplish the learning objective or goal.
In this part Jane has to be very assertive in not only introducing the
topic of research but also to provide examples or some modeling for students to
have a clear understanding. Jane can
provide support to those students by ensuring that the example reaches to all
students with different learning styles.
Have an open discussion to assess if students understood the
instructions of their assignment. Jane
can ask questions to verify that students are in fact clear of the expectations
and the material they will have to cover in the research paper. The following are links that can help Jane.
http://www.crlt.umich.edu/gsis/p2_5
I feel the
lack of guidance is for sure one of the main issues in Jane’s situation. It is imperative that as educators we provide
students with an objective and the clearest expectations of an assignment or
project. Students have the right to
understand exactly the expectations and their roll and participation in
it. Jane could have helped her students
by explaining how the project was going to be conducted and what was expected
of every member of the group. By
informing students that they were going to be not only working in groups but
also collaborating online and setting rules for on online collaboration would
have eliminated some issues. For most
people working in a group presents a challenge, collaborating online makes it
even more challenging. Due to the
collaboration being in a social platform it is especially important to explain
to students the importance of respecting their peer’s work as well as embracing
ideas and modifications that leads to a high quality piece of work. The following link provides excellent tips
and strategies for us teachers to make online collaboration more successful.
Another
issue to address is the fact that in a group assignment every member should
have rights and responsibilities. All
members should take ownership and be able to contribute fairly in order to
receive credit or a grade. Jane could
have worked on a rubric and this would have set the expectations of every
member. It is beneficial to students to
begin learning about collaboration, accountability and responsibility. Teaching students how important it is to be
an active participant of any group assignment will prepare them for assignments
at college and university level. Many of
the times we fail as educators to engage students to feel positive about group
work. It has to start at the elementary
level to change the negative perspective about group assignments. We should share the many of the benefits it
offers to everyone as individuals. This
is a great opportunity to get the student buying so that in their college years
they are ready and active participants of any challenge that presents their
way. By motivating students to go as a
team and hold each other’s hand to create or do an assignment leads to a
community of learners. It also lends to
build the positive social component needed in today’s society. The following links provide assistance for
teachers to create a rubric designed for group assignments.
The
responsibility of the teacher is to serve as a facilitator. As a good facilitator you have to create a
positive atmosphere in the classroom. If
this is created everything else falls in place smoothly. Students have respect for one another,
communication exist and the trust for one another. As a teacher getting to know your students
facilitates the process of leading them and orchestrating any assignment. It is good to be observant of the things that
are working and the things we need to modify in any given lesson. Every child is different and what works with
a class this year might not work with a class the following year. This is the reason it is important to set a
goal, expectations, rubrics and any strategy that will make student’s learning and
academic journey a successful one.